The ‘Big Four’ Showdown: Which collection is the GOAT of Shōnen Anime?

The Big Four have reigned ideally suited because the unchallenged pillars of Shōnen anime for many years and proceed to do to be able to date.

Dragon Ball, One Piece, Bleach, and Naruto are cultural phenomena that experience impressed and birthed entire new generations of the style down the road.

While the previous is regularly known as the grandfather of the 3, they are all similarly influential and well-known international.

But with unending scores and a lot of group wars on who is the best, it is time to put the Big 4 in opposition to each and every different and notice who comes out on most sensible.

By specializing in an anime’s key attributes, I’ll be scoring off the quartet and tallying the entire to look who emerges because the GOAT and absolutely the King of anime.

This web page comprises spoilers from Dragon Ball, One Piece, BLEACH, and Naruto .

1. Plot

Each of the Big Four has distinct plots which spotlight a particular component according to the temper of the collection –

One Piece and Dragon Ball performs up journey,because it suits the full fun-loving really feel of Luffy’s dream to grow to be the Pirate King and Goku’s quest to summon the wish-granting dragon, Shenron.

On the opposite hand, Bleach’s number one function is humanity’s protection via Ichigo’s battles in opposition to the Hollows. In distinction, Naruto’s premise was once curious about garnering recognize through claiming the name of the Hokage.

With each and every display having their respective appeal, it is best to concentrate on their execution of it.

One Piece regulations with its immersive lore, relaxing and sequential build-up, plus smartly positioned plot strains that offer solution for brief adventures and arrange the longer term arcs.

Moreover, it elevates a generic objective, courtesy of Oda’s experience in subtly weaving a very powerful storylines, to ship a superbly balanced narrative of comedy and motion.

While the pacing may also be inconsistent and plot development sluggish, it does compensate with a fair proportion of thrilling moments, lore bombs, or foreshadowing.

Dragon Ball peaked on the unique and Z collection, all due to Toriyama getting old up Goku, increasing the realm and characters with each and every instalment, and incorporating rigidity fuelled cliff-hangers.

The sagas have been concise and problem-driven, providing important milestones within the overarching narrative, making it a really perfect laid-back watch.

However, it persisted to reuse the world-saving or event coaching formulation for each and every collection, thus dulling it down in spite of transferring on from Goku’s number one function.

Naruto and Bleach additionally reflected Dragon Ball’s storytelling taste and excelled in development a compact tale that fulfilled their protagonists’ targets in a wholesome period of time.

Since each plots have been explained through a transparent result and accordingly adapted their development to the display’s grand function, it is a tie between the 2.


Dragon Ball – 8.5/10

One Piece – 9.5/10

Bleach – 9/10

Naruto – 9/10

2. Characters

The Big 4 boasts unforgettable characters that obtain stellar construction during the collection.

One Piece and Dragon Ball pleasure themselves on a various and intensive array of characters.

Toriyama’s ingenuity were given the ball rolling along with his OG forged and their shocking expansion –Vegeta’s personality arc, Frieza’s power-hungry villainy, Piccolo’s reformation, and so a lot more.

But whilst the mangaka threw in a lot of main and supporting characters, he by no means evolved their tale from the beginning, leading to maximum of them being side-lined and downright pointless after sure arcs.

In distinction, Oda perfected the long-lasting shōnen tropes created through the previous and constructed all the One Piece universe on its implausible characters.

Besides intricately fleshing out a forged major forged for twenty years, the mangaka skilfully manages a truckload of characters and nonetheless has each and every one ingrained in everybody’s minds!

Moreover, their interactions are completely gold! Be it between villains, heroes, or each. Also, each and every one has won constant construction during the display.

But the defining distinction that elevates One Piece’s place is the noticeable expansion in its protagonists.

Despite Goku being elderly up within the Z collection, he did not develop out of his naivety and tendency to desert his circle of relatives for a combat. Whereas Luffy no longer handiest holds the torch of the friendship theme however even learns when to name it quits.

Naruto’s line-up additionally wins within the enticing and fleshed-out personality division, however no longer so within the appears. The monotony of Shinobi uniforms and their uninteresting black and inexperienced hues lose their enchantment after some time and faded compared to Oda’s wacky and ambitious designs.

While Bleach’s forged and their expansion are similarly memorable to start with, it quickly begins dealing with issues down the road.

Which is bizarre since, not like One Piece and Dragon Ball, which give the viewer a handy guide a rough get-away from fact, Bleach and Naruto have relatable characters whose issues and behaviour resonate with the huge demographic of teenagers.

Even regardless that Ichigo exudes edgy vibes that scream conventional emo teenager, he nonetheless falls quick because the MC since he has no clean function.

While his sole motivation of defending his benefactors and family members earn him realism issues and counters Naruto and Luffy’s lofty targets, it is usually the rationale his expansion peaked and may just move no additional after the Soul Society arc.

Even regardless that Kubo’s designs are fireplace, the characters’ construction of the secondary forged suffered after the Soul Society arc too. In the top, Bleach’s handiest pleasure was once its villains, in particular Aizen.

Overall, all of them have an ideal begin to their characters and preliminary construction. But Dragon Ball and Bleach lose out on consistency, and Naruto within the design division.

Points: –

Dragon Ball – 8/10

One Piece – 10/10

Bleach – 8.5/10

Naruto – 9/10

3. Themes and Depth

While the Big Three are all closely impressed through Dragon Ball’s theme of loyalty and earnest decision to succeed in one’s targets, each and every one spices it up with their ingenious twists.

Dragon Ball effectively met Shōnen Jump’s Friendship, Victory, and Effort standards however in the long run by no means moved previous its jovial really feel and persisted to reuse its usual tropes.

One Piece betters all its progenitor’s issues or even evokes Naruto with its Nakama thought, as evidenced through Kishimoto ripping off Whitebeard’s speech on betrayal for Kakashi’s rant.

The collection is light-heartedness personified with a lot of laughs and heart-warming moments during Luffy’s voyage.

But it additionally balances its total goofy glance with stealthy intestine punches to the feels via heart-wrenching backstories and the bittersweet aspect of companionship and loss of life by the use of its theme of inheritance of wills.

It even maintains its fun-loving really feel, in spite of the horrific problems it discusses.

Although it may well be whimsical every now and then and virtually all the time have its heroes win, it options crushing losses that stick, not like Dragon Ball’s defeats, which totally desensitizes any sense of dread or rigidity.

On the opposite hand, Naruto portrays a grim global with its theme of generational violence and the complicated but violent aspect of friendship and betrayal.

The ache and trauma of coping with loss are closely emphasised right here, along side isolation and parental overlook.

Bleach suits Naruto’s gore, however its defining theme of the deep want to give protection to amidst the specter of inside demons is what units it aside.

Plus, the thriller of loss of life and the philosophy of lifestyles give it an additional size of intensity not one of the 4 have reached.

Although Naruto and Bleach’s thematic parts are area of interest and centered, handiest the previous portrays it with nuance. In distinction, Bleach’s means is far too glaring and lacks tact.

In the top, Naruto and Bleach do depart a profound have an effect on with their weighty issues. But its execution fails to check the subtly of One Piece’s intensity.

Points: –

Dragon Ball – 8.5/10

One Piece – 10/10

Bleach – 8.5/10

Naruto – 9/10

4. Worldbuilding

The Big 4’s surreal worlds are like no different within the anime universe.

While all boast extremely detailed lore and environments, Dragon Ball and One Piece take the cake with essentially the most intensive and immersive worldbuilding, we now have ever observed.

The former lead the way for the idea that of time go back and forth, the multiverse, area exploration, mysticism, and so a lot more for shōnen anime.

It additionally options a lot of races, from people and anthropomorphic beings to monsters, deities, demons, angels, and androids.

One Piece raises the bar with the ingenuity of Devil Fruits and Haki, plus a library value of information on a number of species and places with their particular person histories that tie to the full tale.

Toriyama and Oda’s fantastically drawn environments and uniquely colourful colour palette supply an additional edge for each collection.

Although Bleach made complete use of interdimensional nation-states through together with Soul Society, Hueco Mondo, and Hell itself, its simplistic aesthetic for complicated and intangible environments dragged it down.

However, it sports activities an array of fascinating Shinigami and Hollow species, hybrids, and variants of human souls. But their amount and diversity are nowhere close to the previous two.

Naruto’s universe is handiest limited to the more than a few Shinobi Clans, the Ōtsutsuki species, and the multi-tailed Beasts.

Although its lore is similarly enticing, it does not encourage a way of puzzle like One Piece and in the long run boils all the way down to an Uchiha vs. Uzumaki battle.

While all 4 deserve props for that includes one-of-a-kind worlds, Naruto and Bleach lose out on additional credit as a result of the previous’s confined global and latter’s uninteresting surroundings aesthetic.

However, Dragon Ball and One Piece have environmental design and artwork taste issues solely reserved for them.

Points: –

Dragon Ball – 10/10

One Piece – 10/10

Bleach – 6.5/10

Naruto – 7.5/10

5. Animation

The Big 4 has blessed the group with massively distinct types of animation that mix effectively with each and every one’s issues and nature.

Dragon Ball Super: Super Hero – Official Trailer 3 (English Sub CC)

Dragon Ball was once the OG of stellar animation even earlier than it become a criterion to pass judgement on anime.

Besides incorporating complicated and dynamic strikes at a easy tempo, it additionally advanced with bombastic motion and brutal combat sequences in each and every collection.

One Piece’s outlandish and exaggerated taste completely suits its characters and their quirky powers. Moreover, it is been regularly making improvements to, with Toei Animation doing an improbable process with the present Wano Country Arc.

The strikes are actually extra polished, with each and every power-up colorfully displayed and accentuated with well-defined motion scenes. However, the complexity of its characters’ actions nonetheless pales in comparison to Naruto.

Speaking of Naruto, it wins through a mile over the previous two with its simple battle sequences and seamless motion, courtesy of Studio Pierrot, who additionally labored on Bleach.

Even regardless that the latter is extensively praised for its high-octane motion, its static and repetitive strikes lavatory it down. However, with the trailer for the Thousand-Year Blood War Arc being absolute fireplace, issues are no doubt open to modify.

With all 4 creatively the use of their distinctive artwork and animation types, it in the long run boils all the way down to an ever-changing record ruled through choice and adjustment.

While hard-core motion fanatics can bask within the glory of Naruto’s completely choreographed battles and Bleach’s well-defined combat sequences, fanatics in need of a wholesome combine of great and fluid motion can delight in Dragon Ball and One Piece’s battles.

BLEACH: Thousand Year Blood War – Official Trailer

But without reference to one’s alternatives, Naruto and Bleach’s sensible animation deserve additional brownie issues for developing the most productive motion sequences.

Points: –

Dragon Ball – 9/10

One Piece – 8.5/10

Bleach – 9/10

Naruto – 10/10

6. Reception

While all 4 boast staggering ratings of fanatics international who root for his or her favourite franchise as the most productive, the Big 3 are dwarfed through Dragon Ball’s international reputation.

Besides influencing all the era of the past due 90s, it continues to carry the beacon for anime international. Goku was once even selected because the ambassador for the Olympic Games in 2020, in spite of One Piece’s takeover years in the past.

Although Oda’s masterpiece reigns ideally suited in Japan, it has but to surpass Dragon Ball’s enormous world achieve.

Bleach is a singular icon some of the 4, but it surely nonetheless cannot achieve the extent of essential acclaim as the previous two. On the opposite hand, Naruto does a lot better with its thematic parts, Kishimoto’s relatable characters, and the long-lasting Naruto run.

While all 4 have grossed billions in manga gross sales, products, video video games, anime, and flicks over time, handiest the Dragon Ball collection and One Piece stand atop the record for its colossal have an effect on that is still as of late.

Points: –

Dragon Ball – 10/10

One Piece – 9/10

Bleach – 7/10

Naruto – 8/10

7. Total Score

One Piece – 95/100

Dragon Ball – 90/100

Naruto – 88/100

Bleach – 81/100

8. Conclusion

The verdicts out! It’s One Piece for the win! With each and every field on an anime’s elementary attributes checked and perfected, it is no wonder Oda’s magnum opus tops The Big 4.

While any record comprising the juggernauts of the shōnen style is vulnerable to alternate, it’s going to take a miracle to dethrone One Piece, particularly with the Wano Country Arc having a look to be the most productive but.

With Bleach’s ultimate season across the nook, the underdog will have the danger to switch puts with Naruto.However, all of it’s driving at the display’s much-awaited grand finale.

Meanwhile, Dragon Ball’s reputation is not prone to fade anytime quickly, thus permitting the progenitor to take a seat very easily at 2nd position in the interim.

Regardless, they will stay Shōnen Jump’s champions for years, as they have got reached heights of good fortune that may by no means be replicated.

Naruto is a Japanese manga collection written and illustrated through Masashi Kishimoto. Its e-newsletter started on September 21, 1999, and persisted until November 10, 2014, in Shueisha’s Weekly Shonen Jump. The manga has accrued 72 volumes in tankōbon layout.

Naruto Shippuden is Part II of the anime collection, which follows an older Naruto as he makes an attempt to avoid wasting his buddy Sasuke whilst on the similar time – addressing the looming risk of the legal group – Akatsuki – who’re focused on him for his or her grander scheme.

Bleach is a Japanese anime tv collection according to Tite Kubo’s manga of the similar identify. The anime collection adapts Kubo’s manga but in addition introduces some new, unique, self-contained tale arcs.

It is primarily based in Karakura Town on a 15-year-old highschool scholar Ichigo Kurosaki who turns into a change Soul Reaper when Rukia Kuchiki, a Soul Reaper, places Soul Reaper powers in Ichigo. They slightly organize to kill the hole.

Although first of all reluctant to just accept the heavy accountability, he starts getting rid of some extra hollows and in addition discovers that a number of of his pals and classmates are spiritually mindful and feature powers of their very own.

Dragon Ball, Akira Toriyama’s brainchild, got here into lifestyles in 1984. It has spawned a number of manga, anime, motion pictures, and different media diversifications.

The preliminary collection follows Son Goku and his adventures when he was once a kid. It is right here that we’re first offered to Goku as he meets Bulma, Yamcha, and others.

He trains in martial arts and participates within the World Martial Arts Championship for the primary time on this collection.

One Piece is a Japanese manga collection written and illustrated through Eiichiro Oda. It has been serialized in Shueisha’s Weekly Shōnen Jump mag since July 22, 1997.

The guy who had got the entirety on this global, the Pirate King, is Gol D. Roger. The ultimate phrases he mentioned on the execution tower have been “My treasures? If you need it, I’ll permit you to have it. Look for it; I left it all at that position.” These phrases despatched many to the seas, chasing their goals, headed towards the Grand Line, searching for One Piece. Thus started a brand new age!

Seeking to be the best pirate on this planet, younger Monkey D. Luffy additionally heads towards the Grand Line searching for One Piece. His various group is becoming a member of him alongside the way in which, consisting of a swordsman, marksman, navigator, prepare dinner, physician, archaeologist, and cyborg-shipwright, this shall be one memorable journey.

Originally Written By Epic Dope

Previous articleChapter 1045: Does Luffy’s Ridiculous stage up make One Piece higher or worse?
Next articlePooja Kava (Actress) Height, Weight, Date of Birth, Age, Wiki, Biography, Boyfriend and More
Derek specializes in writing celeb gossips and TV Shows. He used to watch latest movies and reality shows and write about them.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here